vallisneria vs hornwort - opinions?

[starwave9]

I'm setting up a new 20 gallon planted tank and can't decide between Vallisneria and Hornwort. Which one would you recommend for a beginner? I've got moderate lighting and a basic substrate.

[fineman]

Hornwort's gonna be easier to manage, dude. It grows like crazy and doesn't need much light. Vallisneria can be picky with params, especially if your water's hard.

[trailblazer]

I've had both in my 40 gallon. Vallisneria looks way cooler when it's thriving, but Hornwort's a beast. It'll outcompete algae and give your fish tons of cover.

[tiderip]

Vallisneria's the way to go if you want a clean look. Just keep an eye on your nitrates, it's sensitive to spikes. Hornwort's messy when it sheds.

[velocity]

Hornwort's gonna be easier to manage, dude. It grows like crazy and doesn't need much light. Vallisneria can be picky with params, especially if your water's hard.

I agree with this. Hornwort's been a lifesaver in my low-tech tanks. It's also great for soaking up excess nutrients.

[angler_22]

Vallisneria's roots spread like wildfire if you've got a decent substrate. Just don't plant it too deep, the crown needs light. Hornwort's chill floating or planted.

[stellaNova]

Why not both? Toss some Hornwort in the back for fast growth and Vallisneria up front for that sleek vibe. Just trim the Hornwort before it takes over.

[stellafox]

Hornwort's messy but it's a nitrate sponge. Vallisneria's more finicky but looks way classier. Depends on how much maintenance you wanna do.

[aerialist]

My Vallisneria melted when I switched to RO water. Hornwort didn't care. If your water's unstable, go with Hornwort.

[juloxy]

Vallisneria requires stable conditions. If you're new, Hornwort's the safer bet. It's less likely to die on you while you learn the ropes.